Robotic Pool Cleaners vs Traditional Pool Vacuums

Keeping your pool clean all year round is essential for maintaining safe, hygienic, and crystal-clear water. A dirty pool isn’t just unsightly—it can lead to algae growth and an increased reliance on chemicals, all of which make maintenance more expensive and time-consuming.

Maybe you’ve been manually vacuuming your pool and you’re looking for an easier solution?

If you’ve started searching for pool robots, you’ll quickly realise there are many different types available. The most common choices are robotic pool cleaners and traditional pool vacuums (which include manual, suction and pressure cleaners). But which one is right for you?

In this guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know about robotic pool cleaners vs. pool vacuums, from how each type works to their pros and cons, cost differences, and key factors to consider when choosing the best cleaner for your pool.

Understanding Pool Cleaning Options

All automatic pool cleaners share the same goal: to remove leaves, dirt, algae or bacteria, keeping your water clean and safe. However, they achieve this in different ways. The three main types of automatic pool cleaners are:

1. Suction Cleaners – attaches to your pool’s skimmer box or dedicated suction point on the side of the pool and relies on your main filtration pump’s suction power to collect debris.

2. Pressure Cleaners – connects to a universal wall fitting on the side of your pool (or your pool’s return outlet) and uses pressurised water to propel the cleaner and collect dirt in a filter bag.

3. Robotic Cleaners – self-contained units that have their own electrical supply and therefore work independently of the main pool equipment as well as using advanced motors, brushes, and filtration systems to clean the pool.

Each type has its strengths and weaknesses, so let’s take a closer look at how they work and which one might be the best pool cleaner for your pool.

What is a Robotic Pool Cleaner?

A robot pool vacuum cleaner is an advanced, fully autonomous cleaning device that removes debris from your pool without relying on your pool’s pump or filter system. These machines are powered by their own supply of electricity and operate using low-voltage motors, making them incredibly energy-efficient.

How Robotic Pool Cleaners Work

Unlike suction or pressure cleaners, which depend on your pool’s circulation system, robotic cleaners use independent, onboard filtration. They have built-in motors, brushes and navigation technology that allow them to scrub, vacuum, and filter water all in one.

Most modern robotic pool cleaners come with smart navigation systems, allowing them to map out the most efficient cleaning path while avoiding obstacles like ladders and steps. Some high-end models even feature Wi-Fi connectivity and can be controlled remotely via a smartphone app.

Key Features of Robotic Pool Cleaners

• Autonomous operation – the automatic pool cleaner robot doesn’t require connection to your main pool equipment.

• Smart navigation – uses advanced mapping technology to clean more efficiently; some have sensors to navigate the pool.

• Energy-efficient – uses low-voltage motors, reducing electricity costs, especially as the main pool pump or additional pressure pump is not required.

• Self-contained filtration – removes debris without clogging your pool’s filtration system.

• Cleans floors, walls, and waterlines – covers areas suction and pressure cleaners often miss; use brushes to scrub the surface.

• Programmable cleaning cycles – set timers and cleaning modes for hands-free operation.

• Value for money - while the initial cost is greater than suction and pressure cleaners, pool robots offer significant long-term advantages.

What is a Traditional Automatic Pool Cleaner?

A traditional pool vacuum cleaner (also known as a suction or pressure cleaner) is a device that attaches to your pool’s existing filtration system to clean debris from the pool. In general, pool owners can manually vacuum their pool or can use an automatic vacuum cleaner for pool cleaning, to remove dirt and leaves, clean surfaces and maintain healthy water. While they can be effective, they rely on a number of pool pumps to create suction or water pressure, meaning they can increase wear and tear on your pool equipment over time, and along with additional electricity usage, cost your more $$$ in the long run.

Types of Traditional Automatic Pool Cleaners

1. Suction Cleaners

Suction cleaners attach to your pool’s skimmer box or dedicated suction port. They use the suction from your main filtration pool pump to move around, vacuuming debris such as leaves, dirt and fine dust. Some have rotating scrubbers but most don’t. These cleaners are generally more affordable but have several limitations:

• Increased strain on the pump and filter – suction cleaners rely heavily on the pool pump, which can lead to faster wear.

• May require additional maintenance – fine debris often clogs the cleaner causing jams, requiring frequent cleaning, or part failure.

• Random cleaning pattern – many models lack intelligent navigation, meaning they can miss spots or get stuck.

• Maintenance - often require a tune-up kit of gears and wheels or replacement diaphragm every 18-24 months.

2. Pressure Cleaners

Pressure cleaners use pressurised water from an additional pump (booster pump), or your pool’s return jets, to move around. They are usually triggered to operate for a period of time that the main pool pump is running so there is the cost of two pumps running. These cleaners often have their own debris collection bag, reducing strain on your pool’s filtration system.

• Better for large debris – ideal for leaves and gumnuts, which can clog suction cleaners.

• Require a booster pump – most models need an additional pump for optimal performance, increasing costs.

• Generally lasts longer than suction cleaners – since they don’t rely on the pool filter, they experience less wear.

• Maintenance – also requires servicing every 18-24 months to replace worn parts; can be more difficult to repair than suction cleaners.

Comparing Robotic Pool Cleaners and Traditional Pool Vacuums

Advantages of Robotic Pool Cleaners

• ✅ Fully automated operation – the electric pool vacuum cleaner does all the work for you. Simply plug it in, drop it in your pool, and let it clean. Cordless models require charging before use but offer a cable-free, tangle-free option.

• ✅ Independent from pool equipment – robotic cleaners don’t rely on your pool’s pump or filter, which reduces strain on your pool system and extends its lifespan.

• ✅ Lightweight and easy to handle – robotic cleaners are easy to place in and remove from the pool. They are lightweight and designed for ease of handling, making maintenance simple.

• ✅ Superior cleaning coverage – unlike traditional vacuums, robotic cleaners scrub the floor, walls, and waterline, ensuring a deeper and more thorough clean.

• ✅ Self-contained filtration system – the onboard filter canister captures leaves, dirt, and debris separately, reducing the need for backwashing the pool filter thus saving water.

• ✅ Saves on chemicals and energy costs – because robotic cleaners scrub the surface and improve water circulation, they help reduce chemical use and have lower energy costs compared to running a pool pump (and booster pump) for extended periods.

• ✅ Cordless models available – no tangled cables! Cordless robotic cleaners eliminate the hassle of long cords and make storage easier.

Disadvantages of Robotic Pool Cleaners

• ❌ Higher upfront cost – robotic pool cleaners cost more initially than suction or pressure cleaners. However, their long-term savings on energy and chemicals often make up for the difference.

• ❌ Requires electricity – while robotic cleaners are energy-efficient, they still require power, either through a low-voltage cable or a rechargeable battery. However, they consume significantly less electricity than running a pool pump and booster pump for extended cleaning cycles.

Advantages of Traditional Pool Vacuum Cleaners

• ✅ Lower initial cost – suction and pressure cleaners are generally cheaper upfront than robotic cleaners, making them a budget-friendly option.

• ✅ Uses existing pool equipment – traditional automatic pool cleaners rely on your pool’s pump and filtration system.

✅ Decent cleaning performance for basic maintenance – while not as thorough as robotic cleaners, traditional vacuums can handle routine debris removal when used frequently.

Disadvantages of Traditional Pool Vacuum Cleaners

• ❌ More difficult to install and remove – traditional cleaners require careful connection to the pool system and have long hoses that can get in the way when swimming.

• ❌ Random cleaning pattern – most suction and pressure cleaners lack smart navigation, meaning they often miss spots or repeatedly clean the same areas.

• ❌ Limited cleaning capability – traditional cleaners typically don’t scrub pool walls, steps, or waterlines, leaving some areas less clean compared to pool robots.

• ❌ Higher running costs – traditional vacuums increase pump run time, leading to higher energy costs and more frequent maintenance on your pool’s filtration system.

• ❌ More manual effort required – manual brushing, scooping, and vacuuming (by hand) require significant time and effort, reducing the time you get to enjoy your pool.

Choosing the Best Cleaner for Your Pool

Key Factors to Consider

• Pool Size & Shape – if you have a large or irregularly shaped pool, a robotic cleaner is best due to its intelligent navigation.

• Budget – if cost is your main concern, suction cleaners are the most affordable option, but they require more manual effort and have higher long-term running costs.

• Cleaning Performance – robotic cleaners provide the most thorough clean, covering floors, walls, and waterline.

• Energy Usage – suction and pressure cleaners increase strain on your pool pump, or require an additional booster pump, leading to higher energy bills.

• Maintenance Requirements – robotic cleaners are easier to put in/out of the pool and require occasional filter cleaning, while suction and pressure cleaners are more difficult to install/remove and require frequent pump and filter maintenance.

• Debris Type – If your pool collects large debris (like leaves or gumnuts), a pressure cleaner may be better. If you mostly have smaller leaves and fine dirt, a pool robot or suction cleaner could be a good option.

Robotic vs Other Automatic Pool Cleaners: Which One Should You Choose?

If you prioritise efficiency, convenience, and superior cleaning performance, a robotic pool cleaner is your best bet. It will save you time, energy, and long-term maintenance costs.

However, if you're on a tight budget and don’t mind putting in extra effort, a traditional pool vacuum (suction or pressure) can still be an effective option.

Upgrade Your Pool Routine with Pool Robots Australia

Looking for the best pool cleaning solution? At Pool Robots Australia, we offer expert advice and top-tier robotic pool cleaners to make pool maintenance effortless.

Browse our collection today and let us help you find the perfect cleaner for your pool!

👉 Check out our range of robotic pool cleaners now!